The pun, also called paronomasia, is a form of
word
play which suggests two or more meanings, by exploiting multiple
meanings of words, or of similar-sounding words, for an intended
humorous or
rhetorical effect.[1][2]
These ambiguities can arise from the intentional use of
homophonic,
homographic,
metonymic, or
metaphorical language. A pun differs from a
malapropism in that a malapropism uses an incorrect expression that
alludes to another (usually correct) expression, but a pun uses a
correct expression that alludes to another (sometimes correct but more
often absurdly humorous) expression.
Henri Bergson defined a pun as a sentence or utterance in which "two
different sets of ideas are expressed, and we are confronted with only
one series of words".[3]
Puns may be regarded as
in-jokes or
idiomatic constructions, given that their usage and meaning are
entirely local to a particular language and its culture. For example,
camping is intense (in tents).
Puns are used to create
humor and sometimes require a large vocabulary to understand. Puns
have long been used by comedy writers, such as
William Shakespeare,
Oscar Wilde, and
George Carlin. The Roman playwright
Plautus
is famous for his tendency to make up and change the meaning of words to
create puns in
Latin.[4]
Typology
Puns can be classified in various ways:
The homophonic pun, a common type, uses word pairs which sound
alike (homophones)
but are not synonymous. Walter Redfern exemplified this type with his
statement, "To pun is to treat homonyms as
synonyms."[5]
For example, in
George Carlin's phrase "Atheism is a non-prophet institution", the
word "prophet"
is put in place of its homophone "profit",
altering the common phrase "non-profit
institution". Similarly, the joke "Question: Why do we still have
troops in Germany? Answer: To keep the Russians in
Czech" relies on the aural ambiguity of the homophones "check"
and "Czech".
Often, puns are not strictly homophonic, but play on words of similar,
not identical, sound as in the example from the "Pinky and the Brain"
cartoon film series: "I think so, Brain, but if we give peas a chance,
won't the lima beans feel left out?" which plays with the similar—but
not identical—sound of "peas" and "peace".[6]
Some words are homophones only when spoken in certain accents. Here
are some examples of puns that depend on being pronounced in a
particular accent:
- "Caesar salad" (Scissor salad) in an Italian accent:
-
- Customer: "I'd like a Caesar salad."
- Italian waiter: "Sir! Are you sure you want the
Scissor salad? You'll cut your mouth!"
- "Space" (Spice) in certain accents:
-
- Spice...The final frontier. So much flavour!—Space,
on the other hand, is mostly devoid of flavour and matter.
- (alternatively...)
- Q: What was the name of the first group of female
astronauts? A: The Space Girls.
- "The Nail River" (The Nile River) in certain accents:
-
- Never take your raft down the nail river. It'll pop
instantly.
A homographic pun exploits words which are spelled the same (homographs)
but possess different meanings and sounds. Because of their nature, they
rely on sight more than hearing, contrary to homophonic puns. They are
also known as heteronymic puns. Examples in which the punned
words typically exist in two different
parts of speech often rely on unusual sentence construction, as in
the anecdote: "When asked to explain his large number of children, the
pig answered simply: 'The wild oats of my sow gave us many piglets.' "
An example which combines homophonic and homographic punning is
Douglas Adams's line "You can tune a guitar, but you can't
tuna
fish. Unless of course, you play bass." The phrase uses the
homophonic qualities of "tune a" and "tuna",
as well as the homographic pun on "bass", in which ambiguity is reached
through the identical spellings of
//
(a
string instrument), and
//
(a
kind of fish).
Homonymic puns, another common type, arise from the
exploitation of words which are both homographs and homophones. The
statement "Being in
politics is just like playing
golf: you
are trapped in one bad lie after another" puns on the two
meanings of the word lie as "a deliberate untruth" and as "the
position in which something rests". An adaptation of a joke repeated by
Isaac Asimov gives us "Did you hear about the little moron who
strained himself while running into the screen door?" playing on
"strained" as "to give much effort" and "to filter".[7]
A homonymic pun may also be
polysemic, in which the words must be homonymic and also possess
related meanings, a condition which is often subjective. However,
lexicographers define
polysemes as listed under a single dictionary
lemma (a unique numbered meaning) while homonyms are treated in
separate lemmata.
A compound pun is a statement that contains two or more puns.
For example, a complex statement by
Richard Whately includes four puns: "Why can a man never starve in
the Great
Desert? Because he can eat the sand which is there. But what brought
the sandwiches there? Why,
Noah sent
Ham, and his descendants mustered and bred."[8]
This pun uses "sand which is there/sandwiches there", "Ham/ham",
"mustered/mustard", and "bred/bread". Similarly, the phrase "Piano is
not my Forte" cleverly links two meanings of the words "forte" and
"piano", one for the dynamic markings in music and the second for the
literal meaning of the sentence. Compound puns may also combine two
phrases that share a word. For example, "Where do
mathematicians go on weekends? To a Möbius strip club!" puns on
Möbius strip and
strip club.
A recursive pun is one in which the second aspect of a pun
relies on the understanding of an element in the first. For example the
statement "π
is only half a pie." (π
radians
is 180
degrees, or half a circle, and a
pie is a
complete
circle). Another example is "Infinity
is not in finity", which means infinity is not in
finite range. Another example is "A
Freudian slip is when you say one thing but mean
your mother."[9]
Finally, we are given "Immanuel
doesn't pun, he Kant" by
Oscar Wilde[citation
needed].
Visual puns are used in many logos, emblems, insignia, and
other graphic symbols, in which one or more of the pun aspects are
replaced by a picture. In European
heraldry, this technique is called
canting arms. Visual and other puns and word games are also common
in Dutch
gable stones as well as in some
cartoons,
such as
Lost Consonants and
The Far Side.
Another type of visual pun exists in languages which use non-phonetic
writing. For example, in Chinese, a pun may be based on a similarity in
shape of the written character, despite a complete lack of phonetic
similarity in the words punned upon.[10]
Mark Elvin describes how this "peculiarly Chinese form of visual
punning involved comparing written characters to objects".[11]
Richard J. Alexander notes two additional forms which puns may take:
graphological (sometimes called visual) puns, such as
concrete poetry; and
morphological puns, such as
portmanteaus.[12]
Use
Comedy and jokes
Puns are a common source of
humour
in jokes
and
comedy shows. They are often used in the
punch line of a joke, where they typically give a humorous meaning
to a rather perplexing story. These are also known as
feghoots.
The following example comes from the movie
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World, though the
punchline stems from far older
Vaudeville roots.[13]
The final line puns on the stock phrase "the
lesser of two evils".
-
- Captain Aubrey: "Do you see those two
weevils, Doctor?...Which would you choose?"
- Dr. Maturin: "Neither. There's not a scrap of difference
between them. They're the same species of
Curculio."
- Captain Aubrey: "If you had to choose. If you were forced to
make a choice. If there were no other option."
- Dr. Maturin: "Well, then, if you're going to push me. I
would choose the right-hand weevil. It has significant advantage
in both length and breadth."
- Captain Aubrey: "There, I have you!...Do you not know that
in
the Service, one must always choose the lesser of two
weevils?"
Puns often are used in the titles of comedic
parodies.
A parody of a popular song, movie, etc., may be given a title that hints
at the title of the work being parodied, substituting some of the words
with ones that sound or look similar. Such a title can immediately
communicate both that what follows is a parody and also which work is
about to be parodied, making any further "setup" (introductory
explanation) unnecessary.
Literature
Non-humorous puns were and are a standard rhetorical and poetic
device in
English literature. Puns and other forms of word play have been used
by many famous writers, such as
Alexander Pope,
James Joyce,
Vladimir Nabokov,
Robert Bloch,
Lewis Carroll,
John Donne, and
William Shakespeare, who is estimated to have used over 3,000 puns
in
his plays.[citation
needed]
Here is an example from
Shakespeare's
Richard III:
-
- "Now is the winter of our discontent made glorious summer by
this son of York" (Son/sun)
Shakespeare was also noted for his frequent play with less serious
puns, the "quibbles" of the sort that made
Samuel Johnson complain, "A quibble is to Shakespeare what luminous
vapours are to the traveller! He follows it to all adventures; it is
sure to lead him out of his way, sure to engulf him in the mire. It has
some malignant power over his mind, and its fascinations are
irresistible."[14]
Elsewhere, Johnson disparagingly referred to punning as "the lowest form
of humour".[citation
needed]
In the poem
A Hymn to God the Father,
John Donne, married to
Anne More, reportedly puns repeatedly: "Son/sun" in the second
quoted line, and two compound puns on "Donne/done" and "More/more". All
three are homophonic, with the puns on "more" being both homographic and
capitonymic. The ambiguities serve to introduce several possible
meanings into the verses.
-
- "When Thou hast done, Thou hast not done / For
I have more.
- that at my death Thy Son / Shall shine as he shines
now, and heretofore
- And having done that, Thou hast done; / I fear
no more."
Alfred Hitchcock stated “Puns are the highest form of literature.”[15]
Designation
Like other forms of wordplay, paronomasia is occasionally used for
its attention-getting or mnemonic qualities, making it common in titles
and the names of places, characters, and organizations, and in
advertising and slogans.[16][17]
Many restaurant and shop names use puns:
Cane & Able mobility healthcare, Tiecoon tie shop,
Planet of the Grapes wine and spirits,[18]
as do books, such as
Pies and Prejudice, comics (YU+ME:
dream) and films (Good
Will Hunting). The
Japanese
anime
Speed Racer's original title, Mach GoGoGo! refers to the
English word itself, the Japanese word for five (the
Mach 5's car number), and the name of the show's main character, Go
Mifune. This is also an example of a multilingual pun, full
understanding of which requires knowledge of more than language on the
part of the listener.
Names of characters also often carry puns, such as
Ash Ketchum and
Goku
("kakarot"), the protagonists of the anime series
Pokémon
and
Dragonball, respectively, both franchises which are known for
including second meanings in the names of many of their characters. A
recurring motif in the
Austin Powers films repeatedly puns on names which suggest male
genitalia. In the
science fiction
television series
Star
Trek, "B-4"
is used as the name of one of four
androids models constructed "before" the android
Data, a main character.
The
parallel sequel
The Lion King 1½ advertised with the phrase "You haven't seen
the 1/2 of it!".
Wyborowa Vodka employed the slogan "Enjoyed for centuries straight",
while
Northern Telecom used "Technology the world calls on."[16]
Confusion and alternative uses
There exist subtle differences between paronomasia and other literary
techniques, such as the
double entendre. While puns are often simple wordplay for comedic or
rhetorical effect, a double entendre alludes to a second meaning which
is not contained within the statement or phrase itself, often one which
purposefully disguises the second meaning. As both exploit the use of
intentional double meanings, puns can sometimes be double entendres, and
vice versa. Puns also bear similarities with
paraprosdokian,
syllepsis and
eggcorns.
In addition, homographic puns are sometimes compared to the
stylistic device
antanaclasis, and homophonic puns to
polyptoton. Puns can be used as a type of mnemonic device to enhance
comprehension in an educational setting. Used discreetly, puns can
effectively reinforce content and aid in the retention of material.
Science and
computing
Scientific puns rely on the contrast between precise technical and
imprecise informal definitions of the same word. In
statistical contexts, for example, the word significant is
usually assumed to mean "statistically
significant", which has a precisely defined technical meaning. Using
significant with the layperson meaning "of practical
significance" in such contexts would qualify as punning, such as the
webcomic
xkcd's pun "statistically
significant other".[19]
In formal
linguistics, puns can often be found embedded within the
etymological meaning or usage of words, which in turn may be buried over
time and unknown to native speakers. Puns may also be found in
syntax,
where
morphological constructions have derived from what may have
originally been humorous word play, slang, or otherwise
idiosyncratic word usage.
In
computing,
esoteric programming languages (EPLs) are based in or contain what
may be regarded as conceptual puns, as they typically misuse common
programming concepts in ways which are absurd, or functionally useless.
Some EPL puns may be obvious, such as in the usage of
text images, while other puns are highly conceptual and
understandable to experts only.
In
computer science, the term
type punning refers to a programming technique that subverts or
circumvents the
type system of a
programming language, by allowing a value of a certain type to be
manipulated as a value of a different type.
History
Puns were found in ancient Egypt, where they were heavily used in
development of myths and interpretation of dreams.[20]
In China,
Shen
Tao (ca. 300 BC) used "shih", meaning "power", and "shih", meaning
"position" to say that a king has power because of his position as king.[21]
In ancient Iraq, about 2500 BC, punning was used by scribes to
represent words in
cuneiform.[22]
The Maya are known for having used puns in their hieroglyphic
writing, and for using them in their modern languages.[23]
In Japan, "graphomania" was one type of pun.[24]
See also
Notes
-
^
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary. 2009. Retrieved 7
February 2009
-
^
Dictionary.com. 2009. Retrieved 23 April 2010.
-
^
Augarde, Tony. The Oxford Guide
to Word Games, p.205
-
^
M. Fontaine, Funny Words in
Plautine Comedy, Oxford, 2010.
-
^
Puns, Blackwell, London,
1984
-
^
See the citation on Wikiquote
-
^
Asimov, Isaac.
Isaac Asimov's Treasury of Humor, p. 175, § 252.
1971. Houghton Mifflin. New York.
-
^
Tartakovsky, Joseph (March 28, 2009).
"Pun for the Ages". The New York Times.
-
^
"PUNS". Tnellen.com.
Retrieved 2011-12-20.
-
^
Attardo, Salvatore.
Linguistic Theories of Humor, p.109. Walter de
Gruyter, 1994. Alleton, V. : L'écriture chinoise. Paris,
1970.
-
^
Mark Elvin
"The Spectrum of Accessibility : Types of Humor in The
Destinies of the Flowers in the Mirror", p. 113. In :-
Roger T. Ames (et al.) : Interpreting Culture through
Translation: a Festschrift for D. C. Lau. 1991. pp. 101–118.
-
^ Alexander, Richard
J. Aspects of Verbal Humour in English, pp.21–41
-
^
Levitt,
Paul M. (2002).
Vaudeville Humor: The Collected Jokes, Routines, and Skits of
Ed Lowry. Southern Illinois University Press.
ISBN 978-0-8093-2720-1.
-
^
Samuel Johnson, Preface to
Shakespeare.
-
^
The Dick Cavett Show
(Television production). Unites States of America: American
Broadcasting Company. Event occurs at 8 June 1972.
- ^
a
b
"The Art and Science of the Advertising Slogan".
Adslogans.co.uk. Retrieved
2011-12-20.
-
^
http://leo.aichi-u.ac.jp/~goken/bulletin/pdfs/No16/03AbassF.pdf
-
^
Collins, Michelle (2008-06-06).
"The 50 Best Pun Stores". BestWeekEver.tv.
Retrieved 2012-12-02.
-
^
"Boyfriend". xkcd.
Retrieved 2010-05-07.
-
^
Magic in ancient Egypt by Geraldine Pinch University of
Texas Press, 1995, 191 pages page 68
-
^
Three ways of thought in ancient China by Arthur Waley
Stanford University Press, 1982 – 216 pages, page 81
-
^
Mathematics in ancient Iraq: a social history Eleanor
Robson, Princeton University Press, 2008, 441 pages, page 31
-
^
New theories on the ancient Maya Elin C. Danien, Robert J.
Sharer, University of Pennsylvania. University Museum of
Archaeology and Anthropology, UPenn Museum of Archaeology, 1992
– 245 pages, page 99
-
^
The Cambridge History of Japan: Ancient Japan Delmer M.
Brown, John Whitney Hall, Cambridge University Press, 1993 – 650
pages page 463
References
Further reading
External links